forked from chiki2bum2/SniperGold_ML
204 lines
12 KiB
Markdown
204 lines
12 KiB
Markdown
# P3-GOV-2 — REPOSITORY TRUTH AUDIT
| |||
| |||
```text
| |||
Document type : GOVERNANCE / REPOSITORY TRUTH AUDIT
| |||
Session : P3-GOV-2 (REPOSITORY TRUTH AUDIT & AI ASSISTANT CLAIM RECONCILIATION)
| |||
Date : 2026-08-28
| |||
Read-only : this audit did NOT modify any research artifact, checkpoint,
| |||
MQL5, ML output, Tickstory/dukascopy data, or historical report.
| |||
Final class : B — MOSTLY RECONCILED WITH DOCUMENTED GAPS
| |||
Principal : REPOSITORY TRUTH > AI ASSISTANT CLAIMS
| |||
```
| |||
| |||
## A. Repository identity
| |||
| |||
```text
| |||
Authoritative workspace:
| |||
D:\TradingTerminal\HFM Metatrader 5\MQL5\Shared Projects\SniperGold_ML_authoritative
| |||
| |||
Remote:
| |||
https://forge.mql5.io/chiki2bum2/SniperGold_ML.git
| |||
```
| |||
| |||
## B. Actual Git state
| |||
| |||
```text
| |||
local HEAD : 7e7b6726cf04de85148c3005ed00dc5460da901e
| |||
remote HEAD : 7e7b6726cf04de85148c3005ed00dc5460da901e
| |||
branch : main
| |||
HEAD message: "test: isolate and repair P3-S25.1D interruption recovery verifier"
| |||
working tree: tracked-files CLEAN (only the new P3-GOV-2 governance-audit namespace is
| |||
untracked; committed at close-out)
| |||
stash : NONE
| |||
tags : (none)
| |||
origin : https://forge.mql5.io/chiki2bum2/SniperGold_ML.git (expected)
| |||
```
| |||
| |||
**Baseline: PASS** (local HEAD == origin/main; branch main; no stash; expected origin).
| |||
| |||
## C. Phase reconciliation
| |||
| |||
Every claimed phase Close-SHA was resolved to a full commit object and verified for
| |||
existence, parent chain, and reachability from local HEAD and origin/main. Values below
| |||
are the authoritative resolved SHAs (machine-recorded in
| |||
`ml/p3/governance/p3_gov2_repository_truth_audit/output/claim_reconciliation.json`).
| |||
| |||
| Phase | Claimed state | Resolved commit (authoritative) | Local | origin/main | Rpt | H/O | NS present |
| |||
| ------------ | ------------------------ | ----------------------------------------------- | ----- | ---------- | --- | --- | ---------- |
| |||
| P3-S18 | INCONCLUSIVE | `a1283929d8b92fdac16883143f509907ee424dc2` | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| |||
| P3-S19 | VERIFIED | `84b0e56fc1e6ba2be503f462c4ef1a58e0830915` | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| |||
| P3-S20 | FROZEN weak signal | `7c9602ca4964f42f4ae8b7ac1ea14ab5e49e9176` | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| |||
| P3-S21.1 | descriptive coefs | `49f2f03f85a7a39ba0da115d98e103a98595509c` | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| |||
| P3-S21.2 | B | `da54c9b399eab92f696cbc38d4b4e5d52a764c13` | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| |||
| P3-S21.R | NO SILENT BUG | `ab7d444aa475d2a232d30d676820a7bdc407112f` | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| |||
| P3-S22 | B passed w/ limits | `6e553520e019e492da03831da07f850e4e377dbe` | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| |||
| P3-S22.1 | ADJ-1/ADJ-2 | `ef80fc31b44e6bcf90d4999bffe80b84f0df87da` | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| |||
| P3-S22.2 | ADJ-1/ADJ-2 | `a033e2705fce8b0240a3800050db14b2106c5068` | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| |||
| P3-S22.3 | C - material change | `0ee811e011c149b15d0586517bf24aa616c9e544` | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| |||
| P3-S22.4 | B VALIDATED | `e633baa96c75a2e8830628ce92a627aee4120cce` | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| |||
| P3-S23 | B weak/inconsistent | `a6a804b7ced141f099214dec5b4f705d94835e35` | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| |||
| P3-S24 | D - edge NOT shown | `8f1c80abe72a8db35a5fd1582c68e73033d0843a` | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| |||
| P3-S25 | E-UNRESOLVED | `84465a2e2462801bd906a98a4047ea4ea7568634` | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| |||
| P3-S25.1 | STARTED | `8d631ed58d1bb86d02513b295a72a9c352ddb4be` | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| |||
| P3-S25.1.R | COMPLETE | `390bd9e85c5d32d50848dc3713fd4304d9e6779b` | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| |||
| P3-S25.1 SB | A (chunks 0-10) | `6241383fad6d3405a45472b7e8c6370ee70ae025` | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| |||
| P3-S25.1C | A - chunk size verified | `0b38e96bf8d39afdb6b5ce2069d1b08b5993b619` | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| |||
| P3-S25.1D | COMPLETE (multi-chunk) | `7e7b6726cf04de85148c3005ed00dc5460da901e` | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | folded-into-DR | ✓ |
| |||
| P3-S25.1D-R | COMPLETE (A) | `7e7b6726cf04de85148c3005ed00dc5460da901e` | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| |||
| P3-GOV-1 | CLOSED (B) | `49b174eb4103dc5707c8411c1b3b6c8cec3579be` | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| |||
| |||
**Material commit conflicts: 0.** Every claimed SHA exists as a commit, is linked in the
| |||
parent chain, and is reachable from `origin/main`.
| |||
| |||
Interpretation note (two-commit convention): for phases whose Close-SHA is the phase's
| |||
documentation tip (S18, S19, S20, S21.x, S22, S22.1, S22.2 — the doc recording the phase
| |||
result), the substantive research commit is its parent. For machine-evidence phases
| |||
(S22.3, S22.4, S23, S24, S25, S25.1, S25.1C, S25.1D/D-R, GOV-1) the Close-SHA is the
| |||
substantive/evidence commit (research or combined documentation+research commit). No
| |||
claimed SHA was found to be a bare doc-tip mislabeled as substantive, and no substantive
| |||
commit was mislabeled as the repo tip.
| |||
| |||
## D. Documentation / artifact contradictions
| |||
| |||
| # | Finding | Severity |
| |||
|---| ------- | -------- |
| |||
| D1 | `CURRENT_DECISION_GATE.md` still authorizes "CHUNK 9 ONLY / offset 113,246,416" whereas the real checkpoint is chunk 10 committed / next 11 / offset 163,578,081 | minor-doc |
| |||
| D2 | `README.md` CURRENT-status block pinned at "P3-S25.1C COMPLETE / conclusion D" while `CURRENT_PROJECT_STATE.md` has advanced to "P3-S25.1 Stage-B CHUNK 10 COMPLETE" | minor-doc |
| |||
| D3 | `CURRENT_PROJECT_STATE.md` states `run chunk_size = 25165824 (24 MiB)` but the authoritative checkpoint top-level `chunk_size` field is `12582912` (12 MiB, the initial-run value); per-chunk manifests show 24 MiB for chunks 9-10 only | minor-doc (canonical field record) |
| |||
| D4 | `PROJECT_PHASE_INDEX.md` header "CURRENT AUTHORITATIVE phase = P3-S25.1C COMPLETE (HEAD 0b38e96b...)" is stale after chunks 9-10 and S25.1D | minor-doc |
| |||
| D5 | GOV-1 handover records final SHA `983adbd9...`; GOV-1 tip commit is actually `49b174e` (the commit that wrote that record). `983adbd` is the last substantive GOV-1 classification commit. | minor-doc |
| |||
| |||
None of D1-D5 contradict research/commit evidence; all are documentation/narrative staleness.
| |||
| |||
## E. P3-S25.1 current real checkpoint truth
| |||
| |||
```text
| |||
run_id P3_S251_REAL_TICK_RUN_001
| |||
source_path D:\...\MQL5\Files\XAUUSD_mt5_ticks.csv
| |||
source_sha256 5252ce8f5b0e7d286b71a3172c7ef9c1009c8e4b1254ac67400a803fcd85cba1
| |||
source_size 34,473,661,010 bytes (34.5 GB)
| |||
status CHUNK_COMMITTED
| |||
last_completed_chunk 10
| |||
current_chunk 10
| |||
next chunk 11
| |||
next byte offset 163,578,081
| |||
cumulative rows 3,661,058
| |||
cumulative M15 18,579
| |||
cumulative M30 9,966
| |||
last_timestamp 1,078,220,689
| |||
checkpoint file ml/p3/p3_s251_external_ingest/output/s251_real_checkpoint.json
| |||
checkpoint sha256 47da8f020426bec67e9f7865519e900a28c286ba1d13a15bee6a8c0f5307afc7
| |||
full ingestion NOT COMPLETE (34.5 GB / 722,941,870 rows; ~163.6 MB ingested)
| |||
```
| |||
| |||
Chunk-10 manifest reconciliation: rows 563,266 -> cumulative 3,661,058; M15 2,462 -> 18,579;
| |||
M30 1,317 -> 9,966; byte end 163,578,081. Exact. `CHUNK 11 NOT PROCESSED`.
| |||
| |||
## F. P3-S25.1C truth
| |||
| |||
```text
| |||
SAFE_MAX_CHUNK_SIZE = 24 MiB (25165824 bytes)
| |||
chunk-size invariance = PASS (12/24/48/64 MiB byte-identical; all diffs_vs_reference empty)
| |||
boundary audit = PASS (boundary_audit_ok = true; 5 scenarios all equal)
| |||
mutation detection = 10/10 (target_ratio 10/10, detected_ratio 10/10, all_detected true)
| |||
48/64 MiB tested = yes; NOT promoted to SAFE_MAX; SAFE_MAX stayed 24 MiB
| |||
(evidence-based safe cap; invariance proven up to 64 MiB)
| |||
```
| |||
| |||
## G. P3-S25.1D-R truth
| |||
| |||
```text
| |||
recovery manifest status:
| |||
original_failure_isolated true
| |||
corrected_resume_matches_continuous true
| |||
reproducible_run1_equals_run2 true
| |||
mutation_detection 8/8
| |||
real_checkpoint_unchanged true
| |||
chunk11_processed false
| |||
decision gate (isolated path) A - VERIFIER DEFECT ISOLATED AND FIX VERIFIED
| |||
boundary defect RESUME_BOUNDARY_MISMATCH; earliest divergence chunk 1
| |||
(continuous actual byte_end 25,165,841 vs obsolete nominal 25,165,824)
| |||
root cause DISPOSABLE verifier driver rebuilt resume from obsolete nominal
| |||
split_atomic 24 MiB boundaries instead of actual line-safe consumed
| |||
byte_end. NOT the production parser/aggregator/checkpoint.
| |||
previous failing output: OVERWRITTEN (the interrupted session overwrote the original
| |||
failing JSON before stopping; recorded, not recoverable on disk)
| |||
SAFE_CHUNKS_PER_TURN: NOT SET (broader P3-S25.1D multi-chunk benchmark remains OPEN)
| |||
```
| |||
| |||
## H. Documentation narrative conflicts
| |||
| |||
See D1-D5. All documentation-only; no historical report / machine evidence / commit conflict.
| |||
| |||
## I. Untracked / interrupted work
| |||
| |||
```text
| |||
The only untracked path is ml/p3/governance/ (the P3-GOV-2 audit namespace).
| |||
No CHUNK-11 or interruption-temp remnants present (previous-session untracked S25.1D
| |||
artifacts were committed by HEAD 7e7b672).
| |||
checkpoint before == after : 47da8f02... == 47da8f02... (TRUE)
| |||
```
| |||
| |||
## J. Trust grading (repository provenance, T0-T5)
| |||
| |||
| Phase(s) | Grade | Basis |
| |||
| -------- | ----- | ----- |
| |||
| P3-S18..S20, S21.x, S22, S22.1/22.2 | T3 | committed, remote-reachable, report+handover present |
| |||
| P3-S22.3, P3-S22.4, P3-S23, P3-S24, P3-S25 | T4 | above + machine JSON values verified against claims |
| |||
| P3-S25.1, P3-S25.1.R, P3-S25.1 Stage-B | T4 | above + real checkpoint verified (rows/M15/M30/offset) |
| |||
| P3-S25.1C | T5 | report + JSON + handover + commit reconciled (invariance/10-10/boundary) |
| |||
| P3-S25.1D, P3-S25.1D-R | T5 | report + recovery JSON + handover + commit reconciled (8/8, checkpoint unchanged) |
| |||
| P3-GOV-1 | T4 | governance doc/self-audit JSON present, handover present; final-SHA nuance D5 |
| |||
| |||
## K. Required remediation (recommendations ONLY; nothing changed this session)
| |||
| |||
1. Update `CURRENT_DECISION_GATE.md` next-action to `CHUNK 11 ONLY @ offset 163,578,081` (or the
| |||
owner decision from S25.1D-R handover: close-out of S25.1D benchmark vs continue ingestion).
| |||
2. Align `README.md` CURRENT-status block to `CURRENT_PROJECT_STATE.md` (CHUNK 10 COMPLETE).
| |||
3. Update `PROJECT_PHASE_INDEX.md` CURRENT header to actual tip and add S25.1D/D-R/GOV-1 rows.
| |||
4. Record in the S25.1 checkpoint/state docs that the top-level `chunk_size` field is the
| |||
initial 12 MiB run value; effective per-chunk size lives in each chunk manifest.
| |||
5. GOV-1 handover: state that GOV-1 tip = `49b174e` (substantive classification commit `983adbd`).
| |||
| |||
## L. Final classification
| |||
| |||
```text
| |||
B — MOSTLY RECONCILED WITH DOCUMENTED GAPS
| |||
| |||
Core claims (phase chain, Git SHAs, handover chain, machine evidence, final-state values)
| |||
are supported by and consistent with the authoritative repository and origin/main.
| |||
Remaining gaps are non-critical documentation/narrative staleness (README, DECISION_GATE,
| |||
PROJECT_PHASE_INDEX) and a GOV-1 final-SHA recording nuance. No research claim is
| |||
contradicted by repository or artifact evidence.
| |||
```
| |||
| |||
## Audit integrity self-check
| |||
| |||
```text
| |||
checkpoint immutability : TRUE (47da8f02... before == after)
| |||
reproducibility : TRUE (two semantic runs byte-identical)
| |||
auditor mutation test : 10/10 disposable false claims DETECTED
| |||
machine outputs : ml/p3/governance/p3_gov2_repository_truth_audit/output/*.json
| |||
```
| |||
| |||
*End of P3-GOV-2 repository truth audit.*
|