GetMA() - Moving average calculation
GetBollingerBand() - Bollinger band values
CalculateRiskAmount() - Risk amount from balance and percent
CalculatePipValue() - Pip value calculation
IsSessionActive() - Trading session checking
GetBarTime() - Bar time retrieval
TimeframeToString() - Timeframe conversion
SaveToFile() and LoadFromFile() - File I/O operations
All other utility functions
Removed duplicate function definitions
Added missing m_save_log member variable
Added CloseExternalLog() method implementation
Ensured single definition for each logging and report function
Overview
To fully integrate the enhanced external trade management system, updates are required to 5 out of 7 existing modules. The updates maintain backward compatibility while adding new functionality for external trade handling.
Module Update Requirements
🟢 No Updates Required (2 modules)
TechnicalAnalysis.mqh - Already provides necessary calculations
EntrySystem.mqh - Only handles EA's own entry signals
🟡 Minor Updates (2 modules)
DataTypes.mqh - Add external trade structures and fields
Utilities.mqh - Enhanced logging for external trades
🟠 Moderate Updates (3 modules)
RiskManager.mqh - Enhanced risk enforcement methods
TradeManager.mqh - Improved stop management for externals
Dashboard.mqh - Display external trade information
Integration Steps
Phase 1: Data Structures (DataTypes.mqh)
Add ENUM_EXTERNAL_STATUS enumeration
Extend ManagedTrade structure with external-specific fields
Add ExternalTradeStats structure for metrics
Update DashboardConfig with show_external flag
Key additions:
external_status - Track state of external trade
source_name - Identify where trade came from
stops_modified - Track if we modified the trade
original_sl/tp - Store original values for comparison
Phase 2: Risk Management (RiskManager.mqh)
Add EnforceRiskRulesEnhanced() method
Implement GetExternalExposure() for risk aggregation
Add UpdateExternalStats() for tracking
Enhance ValidateAndAdjustRiskExternal() method
Key features:
Separate risk calculation for external trades
Cache mechanism for performance
Statistical tracking of external positions
Smart risk adjustment without closing trades
Phase 3: Trade Management (TradeManager.mqh)
Add ApplyDefaultStopsEnhanced() with better logic
Implement OverrideExternalStops() with smart override
Create ManageExternalTrade() with different rules
Add ApplyBreakevenExternal() with wider triggers
Key features:
Smart stop override (only improve, never worsen)
Different management rules for external trades
Respect minimum broker distances
Track modification success/failure rates
Phase 4: User Interface (Dashboard.mqh)
Add CreateExternalSection() for display area
Implement UpdateExternalSection() for real-time updates
Add SetCustomText() for flexible display
Create ShowExternalTrades() toggle method
Key features:
Real-time external trade count and risk
Color-coded risk warnings
List of active external positions
Modification statistics display
Phase 5: Logging (Utilities.mqh)
Add LogExternalTrade() for detailed event logging
Create separate CSV log for external trades
Enhance GenerateReportEnhanced() with external section
Add IdentifyTradeSource() for magic number interpretation
Key features:
Separate CSV log for external trade events
Detailed tracking of all modifications
Source identification from magic numbers
Enhanced reporting with external statistics
Key Changes in the Fixed Version:
Testing Mode Detection: Added m_is_testing flag that checks MQLInfoInteger(MQL_TESTER) to detect backtest mode
Conditional File Operations: All file operations are now skipped when in testing mode
Graceful Degradation: The module continues to function without file logging in test mode
Terminal Output: Important messages still print to the terminal during backtesting
Additional Recommendations:
1. Quick Fix Alternative
If you want to test immediately without replacing the file, you can disable logging:
cppinput ENUM_LOG_LEVEL LogLevel = LOG_NONE; // Set to LOG_NONE in inputs
The error "Invalid stop distance: 0.0" was occurring because the entry signals were being generated with invalid (zero) stop distances. This happened when the market volatility (ATR) value was 0 or not properly calculated.
Key Changes Made (Version 6.5.1):
Added GetValidATR() Helper Method in EntrySystem.mqh:
This method ensures we always have a valid ATR value
Includes multiple fallback mechanisms:
Direct ATR calculation if market data is invalid
0.1% of current price as a fallback
Minimum 20 pips for forex pairs
Updated All Entry Strategy Methods to use GetValidATR():
CheckMACrossover()
CheckMAPullback()
CheckMomentum()
CheckContrarian()
CheckBreakout()
CheckMeanReversion()
CheckMultiStrategy()
Enhanced Signal Validation in CheckSignal():
Added explicit check for stop_loss_distance > 0
Signal is rejected if stop distance is invalid
Better error logging to identify which strategy produced invalid signals
Improv
Critical Issues Found
1. Main EA File (ERMT_6.0.mq5)
Missing Definitions:
EnableLogging variable is used but never defined
Timer initialization missing in OnInit()
Timer cleanup missing in OnDeinit()
Performance metrics initialization not called
Duplicate Code:
CheckEntrySignals() function is defined twice (lines 486 and 577)
HelloWorld example code accidentally included (lines 628-685)
Missing Error Handling:
No connection checks in OnTick()
No auto-trading verification
2. DataTypes.mqh Issues
Duplicate Enumerations:
ENUM_TP_STRATEGY and ENUM_TP_MODE serve the same purpose
Should keep only ENUM_TP_MODE
Inconsistent Structure Fields:
TechnicalLevel has both 'score' and 'strength' fields
ManagedTrade references non-existent ENUM_TP_STRATEGY
Missing Initialization Functions:
No init function for PerformanceMetrics
No init function for EntrySignal
3. Module Inconsistencies
Utilities.mqh:
Two commissio
2- Compile and debug - Critical error on exit - OnDeinit
3- Fix for Entry System - Add to OnTick():
4 - ENUM_TECHNICAL_LEVEL enum in DataTypes.mqh -> other Enums and structures DataTypes.mqh v3
The Complete DataTypes Module provides the robust foundation needed for your institutional-grade risk management system, offering better trade tracking, risk analysis, and technical integration capabilities essential for professional algorithmic trading.
Moved modules to inside Advisors post-compile 1 debug; became unversioned
2 -
